In 1916, Oxford University Press published English Critical Essays: Nineteenth Century, selected and edited by Edmund David Jones. It was volume 206 in “The World’s Classics.” This kind of series was once common, especially in the 19th and early 20th centuries, in both Britain and North America. The rise of the middle class and the explosion in literacy fueled the printing of sets like “The World’s Greatest Literature,” “The World’s Greatest Speeches,” and similar works.
These kinds of books were also used in high school and college classes. I’ve seen many of similar size and content that bear educational inscriptions. These works include essays, poetry, short stories, and sometimes single works like a Shakespeare play.
Jones (1869-1941) was known as something of a pioneering schoolmaster. He was born in Wales, and attended schools there, but went to Oxford for his M.A. degree, which he received in 1894. He was headmaster of the Barmouth Intermediate School from 1894 to 1931, when he retired. He edited a number of books for English grammar schools on art, poetry, this volume of nineteenth century essays, and another volume in the Oxford series on essays of the 16th, 17th, and 18th centuries. After his retirement, Jones was a Sunday school teacher. Clearly, education was important to him, something to which he dedicated his entire life.
This particular work was reprinted at least 10 times before the edition I have, published in 1943. And it was republished several times afterward. The last publication date I can find online is 1971—so it was a book that had a pretty decent run from its original publication date.
It’s a small book, just four by six inches. The critical essays Jones included are all about poetry, positioned in chronological order. The essayists include some of the most famous names in poetry, criticism, and political philosophy: William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, William Blake, Charles Lamb, Percy Bysshe Shelley, William Hazlitt, John Henry Cardinal Newman, Thomas Carlyle, Leigh Hunt, Matthew Arnold, John Ruskin, John Stuart Mill, a few other British writers, and two Americans: Ralph Waldo Emerson (writing on Shakespeare) and James Russell Lowell (an essay on Wordsworth).
Wordsworth writes on poetry and poetic diction. Coleridge writes a response to that essay and has one of his own, “Metrical Composition.” Shelley writes a defense of poetry (it needed defending back then, too), while Leigh Hunt attempts to define poetry. The other writers consider Shakespeare, Dante, Tennyson, Robert Browning, Coleridge, and what subjects were appropriate for poetic composition.
Imagine telling a poet today that his or her subject is not appropriate for poetry.
The essay I like best is by William Blake, “The Canterbury Pilgrims,” composed in 1809. It is an atmospheric and character study of Geoffrey Chaucer’s great poem and even a bit of Chaucer himself. Here’s a paragraph that gives an example of Blake’s prose style:
“But I have omitted to speak of a very prominent character, the Pardoner, the Age’s Knave, who always commands and domineers over the high and low vulgar. This man is sent in every age for a rod and scourge, and for a blight, for a trial of men, to divide the classes of men; he is in the most holy sanctuary, and he is suffered by Providence for wise ends, and also has his great use, and his grand leading destiny.”
My volume, purchased at a used book sale, bears a rather slight inscription: “Marilyn Scott, Manly Annex 9, 1946.” I did some cursory searching online but couldn’t identify either the name or the location (a new wing of a museum in a suburb of Sydney didn’t seem to fit). But it suggests a student, likely in England or one of the Dominion countries, using the book for its intended educational purpose. Ms. Scott or a later owner made very minor annotations—a checkmark by the John Henry Cardinal Newman essay in the table of contents, and a few underlined passages in the essay by John Stuart Mill, “Thoughts on Poetry and Its Varieties,” written in 1833 and revised in 1859.
English Critical Essays: Nineteenth Century is a small volume, but it was used in classrooms for almost 60 years. It provided a critical look at poetry and its practitioners. It also provides a window to a world long gone.
How to Read a Poem uses images like the mouse, the hive, the switch (from the Billy Collins poem)—to guide readers into new ways of understanding poems. Anthology included.
“I require all our incoming poetry students—in the MFA I direct—to buy and read this book.”
—Jeanetta Calhoun Mish
- Poets and Poems: Sara Eddy — “Tell the Bees” and “Full Mouth” - June 28, 2022
- “Making Darkness Light: The Lives and Times of John Milton” by Joe Moshenska - June 21, 2022
- Poets and Poems: Paul Mariani and “All That Will Be New” - June 14, 2022