Dutch author Connie Palmen has told an unexpected story.
I’ve read some of the poetry written by English poet Ted Hughes (1930-1998) and American poet Sylvia Plath (1932-1963). I had not read any biographies of either poet. I know the basic facts of their lives—their marriage in 1956, Plath’s death by suicide in 1963—but my knowledge was woefully incomplete. I knew that Hughes had been the British Poet Laureate for a time, and I had seen his memorial stone in the Poet’s Corner of Westminster Abbey.
At some point over the years, I understood that Plath had become something of a feminist icon. Related to this, Hughes was seen as something of a villain regarding his marriage to Plath and often blamed for her suicide. Her death would dog him for 35 years, until his own death. And suicide became a tragic theme in Hughes’ life; the woman he left Plath for committed suicide as well, and his and Plath’s son Nicholas committed suicide.
Hughes had generally refused to talk of his life and marriage with Plath, until the year of his death. In February 1998, he published Birthday Letters, a series of prose poems about his relationship with Plath—his first public statement of any kind about their relationship and marriage. Everyone was surprised; response predictably divided between supporters of Hughes and supporters of Plath.
Palmen fictionalizes the story of Plath and Hughes in Your Story, My Story, translated from the Dutch by Eileen Stevens and Anna Asbury. It’s told largely from the perspective of Hughes, and it’s clear that the author used Birthday Letters as a primary research source. She’s written the story as a series of short, chronological observations, almost like entries in a journal. The book contains no chapter divisions; the only breaks are the spaces between entries.
I found myself interested, then intrigued and finally captivated. It was this passage, very early in the book, that hooked me.
“I loved her—I’ve loved her ever since. If her suicide was the trap she used to catch me, to swallow me, to absorb me, to become one body, she succeeded. A bridegroom taken hostage by death, linked eternally in a posthumous marriage, as inseparable as she wanted me to be from her.
“Her name is my name.
“Her death is my death.”
And thus the title, Your Story, My Story. Plath’s story became Hughes’ story, his story became her story, and the two are linked and paired forever.
It’s a story of passion and fire. From the time they met in 1956, their attraction to each other was intense, almost violently so. That intensity remains a theme, perhaps the theme, of the next seven years. It’s not a relationship marked by nuance and subtlety. Palmen describes a married couple whose lives, and life, are written in large letters and multi-colored pictures. It’s a relationship marked by high drama and extreme feelings, physical, emotional, and spiritual.
It’s a story of two people almost addicted to each other, always running the danger of an overdose. And then it’s no longer a danger but a reality.
Palmen is the author of The Laws, The Friendship, The Heritage, I.M., All Yours, Lucifer, and Journal of a Merciless Year. Her later novels explore the effect of gossip and biographical storytelling on the lives of people. Your Story, My Story was originally published in the Netherlands in 2015 and was recently translated into English.
Given how the stories of both Plath and Hughes have been used to advance political narratives, it might take a novel to get closer to what the truth about these two remarkable poets really is. Your Story, My Story may well be that novel.
How to Read a Poem uses images like the mouse, the hive, the switch (from the Billy Collins poem)—to guide readers into new ways of understanding poems. Anthology included.
“I require all our incoming poetry students—in the MFA I direct—to buy and read this book.”
—Jeanetta Calhoun Mish
- “Making Darkness Light: The Lives and Times of John Milton” by Joe Moshenska - June 21, 2022
- Poets and Poems: Paul Mariani and “All That Will Be New” - June 14, 2022
- Discovered in the Bodleian: “The Lost Tales of Sir Galahad” - June 7, 2022