• Home
  • Prompt Series—FREE
  • For Writers
  • Daily Poem-Subscribe! ✨
  • Teaching Tools
  • BOOKS Etc.
  • Patron Love

Poets and Poems: Grace Schulman’s “Without a Claim”

By Glynn Young 12 Comments

For a time I worked on my own, in a small office in the downtown section of our St. Louis suburb (pop. 27, 154). I was a short half block to our train station, a block from the farmer’s market, next door to the bakery. I was on the first-floor of a two-story building (we call that a skyscraper here), sandwiched between a seamstress’s shop and a hair salon. Most days, my spaniel joined me, sleeping somewhere near my feet.

One morning, I turned on my computer and pulled up AOL (this was years before social media). The first thing I saw was smoke pouring from one of the towers of the World Trade Center. I flipped on my portable television and watched a plane hit the second tower.

The Amtrak station was still half a block away. The farmers market was opening up. I could still smell the leftover fragrance of doughnuts frying at the bakery. The hair stylist had just welcomed her first customer of the day, and the seamstress was working on adjusting a party dress. The dog was still asleep at my feet.

I wasn’t sure whether my immediate environment or the scenes on the television were the more real or unreal.

Can poets and poems make sense of something like this?

Poet Grace Schulman confronts a similar and more individually personal discontinuity in the poem “Hickories, ” included in her new collection Without a Claim:

Why do I write of hickories, whose boughs
touch other boughs across a slender road
when our neighbor, Haneen, born in Gaza,

cried that a missile ripped her niece apart
in the family garden? The child’s father
found her intestines stuck to a cypress bark

and he, too, perished in the raid. Her mother
wrote to Haneen before the news was out,
“Help me. Take my hand.” Why do I rave

of hickories reaching out their crooked fingers?
Because before the fires, the child, Lina,
was dropping almonds into a linen napkin.

Soon she would run to offer them for dinner.
Like Lina, I race to show you hickories,
their nuts shrunken brown globes, soon to fall.

For all the graphic images of missiles, death, and destruction, it is a remarkably quiet poem, and the quietness is what gives it its power. While few of Schulman’s poems in the collection are as unsettling as “Hickories, ” they all share a sense of quiet repose in the face of discontinuity and the futility of what contemporary humanity puts its faith in—technology, power, wealth, music, art, culture, even physical therapy.

But ocean liners will sink, bodies will decay, houses and bridges will eventually collapse. Tragedies happen. Even the subject of a poem like Handel’s Messiah (and one of the poems in the collection is indeed about the Messiah) is ultimately about discontinuity and upheaval.

So we turn to a line of hickory trees to attempt to make sense of a child dying in a missile attack. Or, in the face of the destruction of the buildings of the World Trade Center, even those of us hundreds of miles away and unconnected directly to the tragedy did our own version of writing about hickory trees. We called our spouses, children, relatives and friends, to hear their voices and so assure ourselves that the entire world had not gone mad.

Schulman, the author of six books of poetry and several other works, cites a number of poets as major influences, including Walt Whitman, Gerard Manley Hopkins, Dante, and Marianne Moore. Several are cited or memorialized in the poems of Without a Claim. They, too, are often about change and discontinuity, and how one deals with both.

With quiet words and unsettling subjects and images, Schulman captures our attention and makes us ask the eternal question, “Why?”

Image by h. koppedelaney. Sourced via Flickr. Post by Glynn Young, author of the novels Dancing Priest and A Light Shining, and the just-published Poetry at Work (T. S. Poetry Press). 

Enjoy more poetry at work™. 

Buy the book Poetry at Work. 

Celebrate Poetry at Work Day. 

Browse more poets and poems.

_____________________________

Poetry at Work Day PosterPrint your own free Poetry at Work Day poster and celebrate Poetry at Work Day in your workplace

Visit the official Poetry at Work Day poster page for free printable posters and computer wallpapers

_____________________________

Poetry at Work Business and Poetry Books

  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Glynn Young
Follow Glynn
Glynn Young
Editor and Twitter-Party-Cool-Poem-Weaver at Tweetspeak Poetry
Glynn Young lives in St. Louis where he recently retired as the team leader for Online Strategy & Communications for a Fortune 500 company. Glynn writes poetry, short stories and fiction, and he loves to bike. He is the author of Poetry at Work and the Dancing Priest Series. Find Glynn at Faith, Fiction, Friends.
Glynn Young
Follow Glynn
Latest posts by Glynn Young (see all)
  • An Epic Told in 500 Sonnets: “The Gift of Life” by Amanda Hall - April 6, 2021
  • A Novel About Hughes and Plath: “Your Story, My Story” by Connie Palmen - March 30, 2021
  • Poets and Poems: Osip Mandelstam and “Poems” - March 23, 2021

Related

❤️✨ Sharing is caring

Filed Under: book reviews, Grief Poems, Poems, poetry, poetry reviews, Poets

Comments

  1. Donna says

    January 7, 2014 at 6:47 am

    Such power in quietness, to be sure. Love the way you said that. What a breathtaking poem. Great post. Thanks Glynn.

    Reply
    • Glynn says

      January 7, 2014 at 12:48 pm

      Donna – thanks for reading and commenting. What I keep being reminded of is how much we can learn from the past — and past writers.

      Reply
  2. Martha Orlando says

    January 7, 2014 at 7:48 am

    I think we writers, in general, be it through poetry or prose, try to make sense of this world with our words. This poet whom you featured here is a perfect example. Her poem is quietly brilliant!
    Thanks, Glynn!

    Reply
    • Glynn says

      January 7, 2014 at 12:50 pm

      It’s something, I think, we all do – try to make sense of the world.

      Reply
  3. Maureen Doallas says

    January 7, 2014 at 8:48 am

    Thank you for the introduction to Schulman, Glynn.

    That poem’s plain-spokenness, its every-day matter-of-factness, annihilate. Quiet, yes; and behind it is a fierce determination to not lose hope or fail to see beauty. To give witness is to open our eyes to what we lose.

    Reply
    • Glynn says

      January 7, 2014 at 12:51 pm

      Thanks, Maureen. I really enjoyed this poem (and the collection), and finding out more about Schulman.

      Reply
  4. SimplyDarlene says

    January 7, 2014 at 10:46 am

    Ah, sir Glynn, your third paragraph was as undoing as the poem you shared.

    Love hard in the simple things.

    Blessings.

    Reply
    • Glynn says

      January 7, 2014 at 12:53 pm

      Thanks for the comment, Darlene. As soon as I read that poem, it was like being back in that office 12 years ago.

      Reply
  5. Marcy Terwilliger says

    January 7, 2014 at 11:44 am

    After reading this I see it all so clear in my mind. Why? We are not in control here. Man plans, God laughs. Thanks Glynn it gives you pause.

    Reply
    • Glynn says

      January 7, 2014 at 12:55 pm

      Marcy – thanks for reading and commenting. And it does give pause.

      Reply
  6. Rick Dawson says

    January 7, 2014 at 5:36 pm

    Many years before 9/11, I watched a man get murdered on the streets of Saigon on the evening news before going back to the streets of my sleepy little Massachusetts town to pedal off my dinner – and avoid the insanity within the walls of my home for as long as I could.

    Thanks, Glynn, for reminding me we all have to cope with discontinuities as best we can.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Saturday Review of Books: January 11, 2014 | Semicolon says:
    February 28, 2014 at 7:57 pm

    […] Children of Ashton Place: The Interrupted Tale)7. Seth@Collateral Bloggage (Nascence)8. Glynn (Without a Claim)9. Carol in Oregon (Reading My Own Books Plan)10. Yvann@Readingwithtea (Lean In)11. […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Take How to Read a Poem

Get the Introduction, the Billy Collins poem, and Chapter 1

get the sample now

Welcome to Tweetspeak

New to Tweetspeak Poetry? Start here, in The Mischief Café. You're a regular? Check out our April Menu.

Keep the World Poetic

❤️

Welcome a little patron love, when you help keep the world thoughtful and poetic.

5 FREE POETRY PROMPTS

Get 5 FREE inbox poetry prompts from the popular book How to Write a Poem

Join the Poetry Club

Join the poetry club, when you become a subscriber to Every Day Poems ✨

The classic—Now a Graphic Novel!

"Stunning, heartbreaking, and relevant illustrations"

Callie Feyen, teacher

read a summary of The Yellow Wallpaper

meet The Yellow Wallpaper characters

Recent Comments

  • Megan Willome on Children’s Book Club: ‘Dry’ by Neal Shusterman and Jarrod Shusterman
  • Tammy Cook on National Poetry Month Book Giveaway—Tell Us Your Poetry Story to Enter!
  • Monica Sharman on The Chocolate Artist—From Truffles to Gold Leaf
  • L.L. Barkat on Poet-a-Day: Meet Ashley M. Jones

Featured In

We're happy to have been featured in...

The Huffington Post

The Paris Review

The New York Observer

Tumblr Book News

Stay in Touch With Us

Categories

Learn to Write Form Poems

How to Write an Acrostic

How to Write a Ballad

How to Write a Catalog Poem

How to Write a Ghazal

How to Write a Haiku

How to Write an Ode

How to Write a Pantoum

How to Write a Rondeau

How to Write a Sestina

How to Write a Sonnet

How to Write a Villanelle

Free Printable Poet Bios

Browse all poet bios now

Shakespeare Resources

Poetry Classroom: Sonnet 18

Common Core Picture Poems: Sonnet 73

Sonnet 104 Annotated

Sonnet 116 Annotated

Character Analysis: Romeo and Juliet

Character Analysis: Was Hamlet Sane or Insane?

Why Does Hamlet Wait to Kill the King?

10 Fun Shakespeare Resources

About Shakespeare: Poet and Playwright

Top 10 Shakespeare Sonnets

See all 154 Shakespeare sonnets in our Shakespeare Library!

Explore Work From Black Poets

About Us

  • • Generous-Annual Theme 2021
  • • Our Story
  • • Meet Our Team
  • • Literary Citizenship
  • • Poet Laura
  • • Poetry for Life: The 5 Vital Approaches
  • • T. S. Poetry Press – All Books
  • • Contact Us

Write With Us

  • • 5 FREE Poetry Prompts-Inbox Delivery
  • • 30 Days to Richer Writing Workshop
  • • How to Write Form Poems-Infographics
  • • Poetry Club Tea Date
  • • Poetry Prompts
  • • Submissions

Read With Us

  • • All Our Books
  • • Best Love Poetry
  • • Book Club
  • • Charlotte Perkins Gilman Poems Library
  • • Children’s Book Club
  • • Every Day Poems
  • • Literacy Extras
  • • Literary Analysis
  • • Poems to Listen By: Audio Series
  • • Poets and Poems
  • • VerseWrights Journal
  • • William Blake Poems Arts & Experience Library
  • • William Shakespeare Sonnet Library
  • • 50 States Projects

Celebrate With Us

  • • Poem on Your Pillow Day
  • • Poetic Earth Month
  • • Poet in a Cupcake Day
  • • Poetry at Work Day
  • • Random Acts of Poetry Day
  • • Take Your Poet to School Week
  • • Take Your Poet to Work Day

Gift Ideas

  • • Give the Gift of Every Day Poems
  • • Our Shop
  • • Everybody Loves a Book!

Connect

  • • Donate
  • • Blog Buttons
  • • By Heart
  • • Shop for Tweetspeak Fun Stuff

Copyright © 2021 Tweetspeak Poetry · Site by The Willingham Enterprise · FAQ & Disclosure