Blog, Haiku, poetry

Why Haiku: Not Just 5-7-5

7 Comments 17 December 2012

why haiku

“Why haiku?” I muse yet again after a dozen years of immersion in the genre.

Haiku’s influence is widely seen in English literature, and many prominent writers have taken to it directly: Amy Lowell, Richard Wright, Jack Kerouac, Alan Ginsburg, Gary Snyder, Billy Collins, not to mention last year’s Nobel prize laureate for literature, Thomas Tranströmer:

A cutting wind
moves through the house tonight—
the demons’ names

Yet, for every hundred people familiar with haiku, ninety-nine will cite the seventeen-syllable count as the main hallmark; ironically this is the least valid attribute. English syllables are not equivalent to Japanese on. And the 5-7-5 rhythm is only inherent to the Japanese language. Other languages call for their own rhythms. This has been evident in the haiku journals for some time, where 5-7-5 haiku seldom appear.

What made haiku a eureka discovery for me had nothing to do with syllable count but rather the poetic power of so few words, the alchemy of its techniques and aesthetics. The immediacy of sensory images (the ultimate in show, don’t tell), a sense of time and eternity with a focus on present experience against the backdrop of perennial seasons, the juxtaposition and disjunction of images (most haiku are split into two parts).

a stone, a leaf…
the quiet closing
of a door

-Peggy Willis Lyles

One aim of haiku’s approach is to capture a hard-to-define sense of ma, a Japanese concept that roughly translates as gap, space, or pause. Other far-flung words and phrases associated with ma include interval, silence, white space, atmosphere, nuance, savor, mystery, inexplicability, the forgotten recalled or missing found, a sense of betweenness… In Japan, a haiku can receive no greater compliment than “There is ma.”

In Kyoto,
hearing the cuckoo,
I long for Kyoto

-Basho, translation by Jane Hirshfield

Like all enduring art forms, haiku stays rooted in tradition but continues to evolve. What’s being done with monoku, the one-line form of English-language haiku, is a good example of ongoing experimentation:

the high fizz nerve the low boom blood dead silence

-Jim Kacian

Ironically, perhaps, these musings of mine have already become wordy for a haiku poet. I find myself wanting to return to the simplicity of few words…

a full sail
the sea and sky
one blue

-Christopher Patchel

Photo by Jan Maklak, Creative Commons License via Flickr. Post by Christopher Patchel. His first haiku collection Turn Turn is forthcoming from Red Moon Press.

________________________

Buy a year of Every Day Poems, just $2.99 — Read a poem a day, become a better poet. In December we’re exploring the theme Haiku.

Every Day Poems Driftwood

Your Comments

7 Comments so far

  1. Lovely post, Christopher. Looking forward to your collection.

  2. Chris Yokel says:

    Exactly. This is why most American haiku poets do not maintain the 5-7-5 form, but only the essential idea of haiku, which is capturing a moment.

  3. marianne says:

    love how the sea meets the sky and the horizon blends together.

  4. I have a friend who publishes haiku, and she says it has the longest, most complicated explanations of any poetic form, while yielding some of the shortest poems.


Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Haiku: Pierced by Beauty - Tweetspeak Poetry - December 19, 2012

    [...] so Basho wields his pen, a scalpel instead of a sword—his wounding delicate, surgical, survivable. Pierced [...]

  2. This Week's Top Ten Poetic Picks - Tweetspeak Poetry - December 20, 2012

    [...] that this poem is not written in the well-known 5-7-5 structure. I learned something this week: that’s not a real haiku rule. the ballet of her arms against the [...]

  3. Poetry at Work Day, Done Good - Tweetspeak Poetry - January 18, 2013

    [...] wrote poetry of their own, from full length poems to email by Haiku: [...]

Share with our Community

Post a comment

Get Our Weekly Newsletter

June 17th. Sign up now!

Fiction Jumpstart Workshop. Dream of writing the breakout novel? Jumpstart your fiction by working with best-selling author and award-winning journalist Anthony Connolly.

How to Think Like a Creative Genius Workshop. Need to work especially on your writing voice? Or just want to think more creatively, for personal or professional reasons? Scientist and poet Kathryn Neel will help you build a surprisingly creative life.

Sponsor Poetry (& Happiness)

Every day at Tweetspeak we work hard to bring happiness and personal growth to our audience. Sure, it costs. We could talk about that in terms of what it takes to make a house downpayment, for instance (and not in South Dakota either, you betcha).

Or we could just say this: we do it happily. If you want to be part of that happiness in a small way, you could "Subscribe" for a year. Well, and that would make us happy too. Yep.

We aren't offering anything gimmicky in return. Just a chance to make us smile and keep us mortgage-free. And either way, Tweetspeak will be here for you every day.

We'd love to tweet or Facebook our thanks to you if you sponsor. (And that's no gimmick.) Just tell us not to if you prefer to stay secret.

Sponsor Happiness

Advertisement

Read. Write. Live.

At Tweetspeak Poetry, we are committed to helping people become who they really are. We believe in the power of community reading, writing, and just plain living, to accomplish this.

Read.

Poetry Classroom

Book Club

Write.

Poetry and Fiction Prompts

Poets & Writers Toolkit

Live.

Artist Date

Poetry at Work

Follow Poetry









StumbleUpon Button

Tweetspeak RSS Feed

Google+



Categories

Poetry Button for Your Blog

I Read Light

Click for more button options

Poetry at Work for Your Blog

Poetry at Work-Watch

You can easily follow our inspiring Poetry at Work posts. Add one of our Poetry at Work buttons to your blog or website today!

Click for more button options

Advertisement

More time, less worry. We help creative minds and lives get organised.

________

Tweetspeak generates 3.1 million impressions per month. Advertise with us today. Get heard.

Our Oprah-Listed Title

A Writing Story

Poetry & Quotes to Share

best prose is that which is most full of poetry Woolf photo by Willingham

Grab a great quote for Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, or your blog. We've got everything from tea and chocolate to poetry and writing quotes. Oh, and there's always love or hope, if you need those too.

Make your own WordCandy now

Poetry Prompt Book, Just $2.99

But Of Course

It makes us happy when you click one of our Affiliate Links. Why wouldn't it? :)

All top
I am

© 2013 Tweetspeak Poetry. Powered by WordPress.

Daily Edition Theme by WooThemes - Premium WordPress Themes