“What’s the opportunity here?”
This is the phrase that was playing in my mind after a conversation with my daughter, who is, in her own right, a talented writer and editor—with the possibility to also become a publisher in the future.
At age eighteen, though, she will not be invited (by most of the world) to do any of these things in a significant way that could financially support her. And there is college to think of, first, though we’ve discussed the unusual cases of successful dropouts who’ve changed the world (and made their living doing so).
She’s not particularly interested in taking the “unusual” route, so this is her lot: she must pay her dues before she can viably pursue an editorial profession. Unfortunately, paying one’s dues is not a terribly motivating approach. One could even say it’s downright depressing. Fair enough. But when we are done being depressed (or maybe in the midst of it), it’s helpful to ask, “What’s the opportunity here?”
In a recent discussion with my daughter, I realized things needed reframing. College feels like a holding pattern to her, or just a form of paying dues. I don’t think she’s alone in this; plenty of college students aren’t entirely sure what the connection is between college and their hopes and dreams, or their everyday lives as they wish to live them. What to do?
I suggested picturing the experience as a four-year writer-in-residence type of opportunity or an extended conference, but maybe even better, because she’ll get 4+ months off—a few times over—during several of those years.
“Let’s make a business plan, ” I suggested. Then I started thinking—what in the world should go in it? Figuring the elements of the plan would be the fun part, at least I hoped. As a publisher myself, who might want to hire someone like her after graduation, I’d probably add at least these goals towards the business of becoming an editor…
Dear Young Editor, Here’s a Possible Plan,
1. Treat your classes like writing workshops, whether or not they are. In my daughter’s case, she’s a philosophy major. What would it look like to sit down with each assignment not so much as a student of Plato (or Dr. So-and-So), but as someone whose goal it is to have a higher level of writing skills than the next guy and a swift, effective ability to revise?
2. Try to meet people who are good writers and thinkers. Score, on the thinking, if you’re in the philosophy major. Are you willing to work? Consider applying to be a TA, especially if the role includes reviewing student papers. If you discover someone who’s clearly a good writer, keep her in mind as someone you could help to eventually publish. You want to be an editor, after all. You’ve got to start thinking about people who may have a writing future (did you know that Dr. Seuss got a big break from a former college buddy who had become an editor?). You might also decide to take some classes in the writing department, even if you yourself aren’t so interested in such classes. These are future writers! Or at least they’re demonstrating a desire to be. What can you learn from listening to their hopes (and seeing where their struggles lie)? How can you hone your editorial advisement skills by being in their midst?
3. In your spare time, keep reading at those fan fiction sites. You love it, and you might meet someone you’d like to publish someday. It also keeps you thinking about what makes good writing. Well, and you love it. Editors should always be reading something they love.
4. For the sake of both skill and credibility, try to get your own writing published, taking a “ladder” approach (if you have to start with the college lit journal, start there, and keep reaching upwards towards more challenging markets). Trying to get published will keep you kinder to writers, as you’ll remember what it’s like to be submitting work, receiving feedback, and having your writing sometimes rejected. The summer might be a perfect time to concentrate on writing and submitting articles, stories, and poems. During the college year, you could go an alternate route and see if there are any departments that might need copy writing or proofreading services. This gets you doing light editorial work on a professional level, in an environment you don’t have to go far to find.
5. Discover and develop the tools to be organized (like Workflowy and Todoist, for example). Of course, the demands of college make this an optimal goal far before graduation, and there is ample occasion for practice. As for being an editor, the best ones are not people a publisher has to follow around and keep tabs on. (Take it from me, a publisher.) Also, most publications or book projects have strong deadlines and milestones. Being able to work in such a time-sensitive context is vital. (Not sure you can deal with deadlines? Then it’s time to be a famous writer who publishers will give a little grace to. But first you’ll have to… pay your writing dues.)
6. Learn diplomacy. Writers are sensitive about their work, or can be. Think about this: which teachers do you enjoy getting feedback about your work from and why? Who disappoints you and why? One is the better “editor, ” and one is the worse. One may be diplomatic and one may be blunt. One may be useless in giving you insight and one may be right on. What makes the difference? How can this tutor you as you look to your own ways of giving feedback about writing? (Understandably, the problem with some teachers is they simply think of themselves as evaluators and graders. This is unfortunate. But you can still learn from their style—and remember that working with a writer is also a form of “grading” or “evaluating, ” because you will have the power to publish them or not. The key is in how feedback is given—diplomacy desired!—and whether it helps a writer grow and make their work better or, if you must hand out a rejection, whether a writer gets to walk away with her heart intact.)
7. Read widely, across genres and subjects. Do you have to take “core” classes? See them as chances to accomplish this and explore ideas, facts, and works you might not otherwise have come across. Reading widely will make you a more knowledgeable editor who can handle a variety of projects (plus, it can make you and your own writing more interesting; my daughter, who has read Socrates for the philosophy major is pretty sure that Rowling’s read him too and modeled some of Dumbledore’s ideas on his).
8. Develop an understanding of the publishing process (including marketing, even if you have no intentions whatsoever of being in the marketing department), because as an editor you’ll need an eye for the marketing “angle” of a work-in-progress or a completed work you wish to acquire. You’ll also need to see which writers and authors have the kinds of marketing skills you’ll find valuable as an editor (and maybe a future publisher). And, to some extent, you’ll be involved in marketing the works you publish, if only in side-door ways. You can develop a marketing perspective by taking a class in the subject or being involved with a college publication that includes marketing as part of what you do. Interning with a publisher can help you learn about other aspects of the publishing process. And, simply reading in the industry can help you get a view of what it takes across the board to be a publisher (be sure to read Jane Friedman and Publishers Weekly, for instance). It’s okay if you’d rather stick with being an editor for the duration of your professional future, but you’ll be a more valuable editor if you understand the workings of publishing beyond just your particular job.
The End of the Matter
These are just some of the college goals (opportunities) a young editor-hopeful like my daughter might have. To look towards being a publisher someday is an even bigger goal. And the question—across a variety of situations that will arise—stands, “What’s the opportunity here?”
After a recent experience with my own publishing business, where a 3rd-party technology failure caused a big loss for us, I posed the opportunity question to myself. It seemed… only fair, given that I wanted my daughter to think on the question for her own circumstances. At first, I answered in the negative. “There is no opportunity here.” Which is exactly how I felt after this event I had no control over.
Then I decided that, if nothing else, it was an opportunity to exercise faith in the long-term efforts of my business (and a reminder to never put all your eggs in one basket). In a roundabout way, it also spurred me to write this article. Which you can see was an opportunity—if not for me, then hopefully for a young editor to be.
Photo by Mike, Creative Commons, via Flickr.
A Little Help for Your Writing and Editing Life
Check out On Being a Writer: 12 Simple Habits for a Writing Life that Lasts. Written by two editors and writers who have created long-term, successful careers, this book is, in the words of popular author Philip Gulley, “A winner.”
Buy ‘On Being a Writer’ on Amazon
Download Free Excerpt at Noisetrade
- Where Poetry Lives—Interview with Beekeeper & Poet Sara Eddy - August 16, 2022
- Tell the Bees: A Little Chat Highlight - August 9, 2022
- Tell the Bees—Event This Friday, August 5 + Prompt! - July 11, 2022
Donna says
I’m a big believer in ‘nothing is wasted’ 🙂
Opportunity reall is everywhere. I saw that on a wordcandy, you know. In a teacup with purple violets.
I love this advice, and although my own son would have none of it at the time, I continue to shine a light on opporutinities along the path – whichever path he chooses. I didn’t think he was listening, and in fact I thought he was getting pretty sick of hearing me share the flip side of things. However, one day, there were my words coming out of his mouth – “I guess there is a bright side to this….” Truthfully, I can’t remember what the bright side was, but the fact that he noticed an opportunity where it would have been easy to just trash a ‘thing’ made my heart smile. No matter which path you walk in life, it’s good to have an eye trained to see the opportunities – even if it is an opportunity to do nothing and simply practice faith and patience.
I really like the advice about using every class as a writing workshop…. all of the advice, in fact, seems to hold useful gems for any student. Whatever that class has to offer, take it and use it. Make it give you your money’s worth. Some of the biggest learning opportunities may have nothing to do with the subject matter at all.
L. L. Barkat says
It took me a while in life to come to that conclusion “nothing is wasted”— I guess I needed that teacup earlier on! ;-)—but once I did it began to change almost every circumstance I come across.
My daughter was laughing when she read (and edited) this piece. “You are always looking for the opportunity in things. You’re always telling us that.” (Nothing new under the L.L. sun, ha 🙂 )
L. L. Barkat says
Oh, and a quick question.
Is there anything you would add regarding what it takes to be a great editor? (It’s fine to give this from a writer’s perspective, even preferable, since I am coming at this more from the editor side of things.)
Donna says
One piece of advice would be to continue to guard and nurture one’s own social media and online presence. I know that you have really focused on this with your daughters, and it’s vital. Of course there are the obvious reasons – that language and vulgarity and highly polarized posts can lead to judgements and trouble in the workplace and in advancement decisions at the college and workplace levels…
However, the OTHER reason is for the portfolio/networking/platform potential that can be created there. Editors don’t start out as editors, and I think the internet can be a huge help when creating, I guess you’d call it, your brand. Not that I think a young college student should be that worried about creating a brand while things are so fluid and exciting – but getting your work out there (or your play) gives you not only an opportunity to practice being ‘seen’, but it gives you something to show others who want to know what you can do — I’m a big fan of using the internet so that you have a place to sent people who need to know your work – prospective employers, as writing samples for free lance work, or as a living portfolio for future education endeavors.
Donna says
I know this is not really “college” related, but I think the college age group (traditional students, by age, I mean) are expecially vulnerable to getting caught up and derailed by the internet. What they are working so hard to create for themselves can be quickly destroyed online… or helped.
Donna says
LOL did I really type EXPECIALLY? Oh dear, I need an editor, quick! 🙂
L. L. Barkat says
Fantastic point. Yes, we have worked very hard on that matter. If they want “play” places on the Internet, those are all done with pseudonyms. Anything that truly points to them is being used as a way to showcase their work and professionalism. When they were quite young, I also bought the domains for their real names. (Something I advise every parent to do, if they think their child will be needing an online professional presence.)
Donna says
I took that advice and got our youngest a domain name a few years ago. He hasn’t really used it yet, but I’m pretty sure it will come in handy as he develops his gaming and tech persona.
So funny – I was giving him guff about something he had posted on line about not wanting to go to work and he said “But Mom, I don’t even USE my real NAME so who will find me but my own friends?” LOL oh yeah… I forgot that when he was young I wanted his identity concealed online. Made me laugh. He got me!
Megan Willome says
I like the idea of play places under a pseudonym. Recently, I heard Brene Brown say that she only shares stories that serve her work. That means there are stories she doesn’t share. I’m finding that to be a good guideline. If it doesn’t serve the work, maybe it’s for play elsewhere.
Maureen says
Great advice.
Some possible additions:
– Consider joining an existing college publication or start one of your own.
– Consider working with a professor on his or her research projects (I did this through my work-study program because I qualified for student aid. A lot can be learned this way.)
– Always look at the opportunities boards the college maintains.
– Set a high standard but understand that sometimes “it’s good enough”.
– Don’t limit yourself by specializing. The greater your curiosity, the more you explore, the better the writer or editor you’ll become.
Donna says
Great advice Maureen… I especially love that last one!
L. L. Barkat says
I love the idea of starting her own publication. That might eventually be something she’d really shine at.
I also love the idea of working on research projects with a professor. She just signed up to participate in a psychology study (which is actually even a paid thing), and wouldn’t it be cool if she then got involved with compiling the results and watching the process of taking it to journal publishing stage.
I am happy to report that both my girls are curious and curiouser. Perhaps the home education helped in this regard. But it’s something that people who work with them always comment on. They are fascinated by every little thing.
Simply Darlene says
What are ways she can combine her current course of study with her future goals? A variation, idea, extension of your #4 above.
(Before my stint at law school I was advised by several people to read Scott Turow’s, “One L: The Turbulent True Story of a First Year at Harvard Law School.” Even though it’s dated like a journal, it reads like a novel, all while sounding like a conversation with a friend. And how I needed all of that.)
With her writerly background and literary skillset, your daughter is in a unique position. The opportunities abound!
L. L. Barkat says
Interestingly, she is not keen on being a Creative Writing or a Lit major, and I actually think that’s good. To me, many of the most intriguing writers have specialized things to write about (case in point… LW here at Tweetspeak often writes about being a claim adjuster and it’s fascinating, at least to me 🙂
So I often advise writing-hopeful kids to major in subjects that have deep roots in other fields. History, Philosophy, Science, Art. It will give them more to write about, in an informed way.
How fun. I never knew you’d been interested in Law!
Caroline Gerardo says
I like #2 the best- I say to my college children: pick the smart people, invite the creatives to eat with you in the dining hall, speak to those who are different, and friend those who are brilliant.
L. L. Barkat says
So much is about the people. That’s something I’ve learned at conferences, too. I used to go more for the content, and then I started choosing sessions based on the people instead. 🙂 (What are you children’s majors?)